
Fontainebleau Miami Beach
Best for big-group travel, nightlife, and a wide choice of restaurants and pool experiences.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Fontainebleau Miami Beach is a large, entertainment-forward oceanfront resort in Mid‑Beach with many pools, restaurants, a major nightclub, and big-event capacity. The Shelborne By Proper is a smaller, design-led South Beach beachfront hotel for travelers who want stylish rooms and a quieter, lifestyle-focused stay.
Updated · about 3.2 miles (5.1 km) apart

Best for big-group travel, nightlife, and a wide choice of restaurants and pool experiences.

Best for travelers who want a design-forward South Beach stay with direct beach access and a compact, stylish property.
When Fontainebleau Miami Beach wins: Choose Fontainebleau if you want a full-service resort with many pools (11 distinct pool experiences), a wide range of signature restaurants and bars, a large spa (Lapis Spa), family-friendly amenities, and on-site nightlife (LIV nightclub).
When The Shelborne By Proper wins: Choose The Shelborne if you prefer a smaller, design-focused South Beach hotel with beachfront access and a more intimate, lifestyle feel close to Lincoln Road and the Boardwalk.
Bottom line: Fontainebleau is the choice for scale, variety, family options, and nightlife; The Shelborne is the better pick for a compact, stylish South Beach beachfront stay with easier walking access to Lincoln Road and South Beach attractions.
| Category | Fontainebleau Miami Beach | The Shelborne By Proper |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Large, resort-scale property focused on entertainment, dining, and events | Stylish, design-forward South Beach beachfront hotel |
| Location | Mid‑Beach (4441 Collins Avenue) — directly on the Atlantic; near Miami Beach Boardwalk | South Beach (1801 Collins Avenue) — on Collins Avenue, steps from the boardwalk and Lincoln Road |
| Size | Resort with many room types (22 listed room types) and large event capacity | Smaller hotel with 251 rooms (listing shows 251 rooms) |
| Families / ages | All-ages resort with family pools and childcare options; also has adults-only spaces | All-ages property (not adults-only) with a more adult-styled boutique atmosphere |
| Pools | Extensive poolscape — 11 distinct pool experiences including family pools and a 21+ day club (Arkadia) | One outdoor pool plus private beach access and poolside amenities |
| Beach | Direct beach access; umbrellas, loungers, cabanas available for rent; beach open sunrise–6 PM | |
| Restaurants & bars | About 12 restaurants & bars (Hakkasan, Prime 54, Mirabella, La Côte, Bleau Bar, etc.) | One on-site restaurant (Pauline) plus a coffee shop/cafe and multiple bars/lounges (3 bars/lounges, 1 beach bar) |
| Spa & wellness | Lapis Spa — 40,000 sq ft, hydrotherapy circuit, sauna; adults-only spa facility | On-site spa access listed but detailed spa size and signature facilities — Not published |
| Nightlife & events | On-site LIV Nightclub and large conference/ballroom space for big events | Smaller meeting/event capacity (6 meeting rooms; 30,000 sq ft conference space listed) |
| Wi‑Fi & business | Free Wi‑Fi in rooms and public areas; extensive event and meeting facilities | Complimentary wired and wireless internet; 6 meeting rooms and 30,000 sq ft of event space |
Fontainebleau sits in Mid‑Beach at 4441 Collins Avenue, directly on the Atlantic and adjacent to the Miami Beach Boardwalk.
Pick Fontainebleau if you want a large beachfront resort slightly north of core South Beach attractions.
The Shelborne is a design-forward beachfront hotel on Collins Avenue in South Beach, close to Lincoln Road and the boardwalk.
Pick The Shelborne for a walkable South Beach base with immediate access to Lincoln Road and the boardwalk.
Fontainebleau offers a wide range of room types and many larger suites for groups.
Fontainebleau is better if you need many room choices and larger suites for groups or families.
The Shelborne lists 251 air‑conditioned rooms and a selection of city- and ocean-view rooms, studios, suites, and villa options.
The Shelborne focuses on stylish room choices with several oceanfront options in a compact property.
Fontainebleau is a dining destination with multiple signature restaurants and lounges.
Choose Fontainebleau if you want a broad range of restaurant styles and late-night bar options on property.
The Shelborne offers a more limited on-site dining program focused on a signature restaurant and beach/pool service.
The Shelborne works well if you plan to eat out in South Beach often and want a simpler on-site dining set.
Fontainebleau's extensive poolscape is a major draw, with 11 distinct pool experiences.
If pool variety and a resort pool scene matter, Fontainebleau is the clear choice.
The Shelborne has one outdoor pool and direct private beach access with beach loungers and cabanas.
The Shelborne suits guests who prioritize direct beach time and a quieter pool scene over many pool choices.
Fontainebleau pairs a large, adults-only Lapis Spa with on-site clubbing at LIV.
Fontainebleau is stronger where a full-service spa and on-site nightlife matter.
The Shelborne emphasizes fitness classes and a quieter nightlife profile on a smaller property footprint.
The Shelborne fits travelers seeking wellness and beach time without the resort-club scene.

Fontainebleau — on-site LIV nightclub, many bars, large ballrooms and convention space.

The Shelborne — steps from Lincoln Road and the boardwalk with direct beach access in South Beach.

Fontainebleau — 11 distinct pool experiences including a family pool and a 21+ day club.

The Shelborne — design-hotel positioning with stylish rooms and a more intimate scale.
The Shelborne — it's in South Beach and within walking distance of Lincoln Road and the boardwalk; Fontainebleau is in Mid‑Beach and is a short drive from South Beach attractions.
Fontainebleau — it lists family pools, a children's waterscape, supervised childcare options, and family room configurations; The Shelborne is family‑friendly but is smaller and more adult‑oriented in its design.
Yes — both properties offer direct beach access with loungers and umbrella/cabana options.
No — The Shelborne By Proper is not adults-only according to the supplier listing.
Explore how Fontainebleau Miami Beach stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·